Tuesday, January 7, 2014

Kelroy/Kristeva/TheFollowing


Today I read the next fifty pages of Kelroy. Mrs. Hammond has little problem marrying off Lucy, her older daughter, to Walsingham, an English gentleman visiting the US for an extended period. This is partly because Lucy shares her mother’s mercenary spirit and partly because Walsingham is so easily taken in by Lucy’s beauty that he either doesn’t notice or doesn’t trouble himself overmuch about signs of Lucy’s selfishness and shallowness. It’s interesting to read a novel from this period in which the male is the victim of the marriage plot rather than its villainous initiator, although this book does have its fair share of male villains, too. Mrs. Hammond has a much more difficult time with her younger daughter, Emily, who is the sympathetic protagonist of the story. Unlike Lucy, Emily’s nature disinclines her to be overly influenced by her mother’s ambitions for her, and she retains too much innocence and good humor to marry for the wrong reasons. When Kelroy, a poet with precarious financial prospects, enters the narrative, Mrs. Hammond is horrified to see he and Emily falling for each other. The fact of Emily’s happiness matters not to Mrs. Hammond; she merely cares about having Emily marry ‘well’ so that her financial difficulties may be alleviated once and for all. How much of the disapproval we’re encouraged to feel for Mrs. Hammond’s actions come from the fact that she’s a woman? Would we condemn a man performing identical actions with the same motives? And can we blame Mrs. Hammond for placing pecuniary considerations before everything else? What other choice does she have?

I also read the next fifty pages of Julia Kristeva’s This Incredible Need to Believe. In this section of the book, Kristeva discusses the concept of genius in detail as another possible bulwark against nihilism. She has no interest in renovating the traditional concept of romantic genius, and yet she does not want to dismiss the concept altogether. Why not? Because she believes that nihilistic depression comes from “the programmed decline of the singularity…which slumbers within each one of us.” Acts or works of genius can therefore stimulate this singularity: “the intelligence of the extreme singularity (as manifested in exceptional works of art, for instance) that calls out to the singularity of each one of us, is the only possible therapy for this banalization” (italics in original). The other thing that struck me about this section of the book was Kristeva’s treatment of Christianity and Islam. At the risk of oversimplifying a complex argument, I would say that she tends to treat Christianity too generously and Islam too harshly by underemphasizing the problem of fundamentalism in the latter and overemphasizing it in the latter. This may be a consequence of Kristeva’s Eurocentric emphasis; American Christian fundamentalism is only mentioned briefly and deserves much more attention.

Take all the standard ingredients of the serial killer tv drama—a ‘brilliant,’ charismatic and preferably non-American killer; a haunted and traumatized FBI agent; an immense yet curiously ineffective law enforcement system; lots of female victims; lots of blood to cover up plot holes, and psychobabble of one kind or another—and put them in a blender. But—and this is important—don’t blend them until they’re smooth. Instead, blend them half-way until it’s a mess of indigestible chunks. Congratulations! You’ve just made ‘The Following.’ We have a lot of episodes to get through in this first season and so lots of time to list all my objections, but let’s start with this one: I’ve been an English professor (from England, no less!) in America who teaches Poe regularly for over 20 years and the notion that a charismatic professor influences his students to obey him blindly is, I’m sorry to say, not true. I can barely persuade my students to complete assignments, let alone form a death cult and kill at my bidding. Perhaps I’m not trying hard enough.

Monday, January 6, 2014

Kelroy/Kristeva/Muoi


Today I read the first fifty pages of Kelroy, a novel written by Rebecca Rush and published in 1812. http://books.google.com/books/about/Kelroy.html?id=ZHKYQgAACAAJ. Republished as part of OUP’s Early American Women Writers series, in her Foreword, Cathy Davidson describes Kelroy as representing the “dark underside of sentimentalism,” while Dana Nelson, in her Introduction, writes that the novel “exposes a social system that limits the physical, educational, professional, and economic aspirations of women.” In this regard, it’s striking that the novel’s main villain is female. Mrs. Hammond, having been left in financially straitened circumstances by the unexpected death of her husband, and being too old to make another advantageous marriage, realizes that her two daughters are her best chance of recovering her fortunes and ensuring that she spends the rest of her life in comfort. Accordingly, she trains both daughters carefully in the social graces that will make them attractive and valuable commodities on the marriage market. Although the novel may be critical of Mrs. Hammond’s selfishness and her purely instrumental attitude toward her children, at no point is it suggested that she is inaccurate in her assessment of the values of the society of which she is a part. In this regard, Kelroy’s cynical assessment of early republican American culture is of great interest to a contemporary audience.

I also read the first fifty pages of Julia Kristeva’s 2009 book, This Incredible Need to Believe (originally published as Bisogno di credere: Un punto di vista laico in 2006). http://cup.columbia.edu/book/978-0-231-14784-2/this-incredible-need-to-believe. A combination of an extended interview and shorter occasional pieces, this book is physically slighter than many of Kristeva’s other works, but is no less ambitious. Her focus is on “the need to believe,” which Kristeva describes as “that narcotic that makes living easier, for—happy infantile and amorous trauma—it is the foundation of our capacity to be…speaking beings.” Kristeva elaborates on the foundational status of this need to believe, which we might also call faith, in order to achieve several related goals, including establishing a resistance to both nihilism and religious fundamentalism, as well as a qualified defense of religion, which, as Kristeva puts it, unlike Freud, she refuses to dismiss as an illusion. As thought-provoking as ever, for me the most striking moment of this first section of the book comes when her interviewer asks Kristeva to comment about youth riots in the suburban ghettos/banlieues of France. While acknowledging the social and political problems that motivate the riots, Kristeva insists that “the delinquency of ‘disadvantaged teens’ reveals a more radical phase of nihilism.” Not surprisingly, Kristeva prefers to grapple with the meaning of the riots as a primarily psychic rather than a material phenomenon and in doing so she reveals both the characteristic strengths and the limits of her approach.

I also watched Muoi: The Legend of a Portrait, a 2007 South Korean/Vietnamese horror film directed by Kim Tae-kyeong. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-cPh3ocypJY. Apart from its historical importance (it’s the first horror film produced in Vietnam since the end of the Vietnam War), this film owes a great deal to the vogue for supernatural horror vengeance stories popular in both Japanese and Korean cinema since the late 1990s. Yun-hee, a South Korean writer, travels to Vietnam to see her old friend Seo-yeon, who has promised to tell her about a local Vietnamese legend involving a girl named Muoi and her haunted portrait. Once she arrives in Vietnam, Yun-hee finds herself caught in a trap set by Seo-yeon, who wants revenge not only on Yun-hee (who has ruined Seo-yeon’s reputation by writing about her in Yun-hee’s best-selling book) but also on Yun-hee’s friends, who were responsible for filming Seo-yeon’s gang-rape some years before. This plot will sound familiar to fans of the genre, but two things set it apart: the first is its Vietnamese setting and its exploration of Korean-Vietnamese relations, and the second is the fact that Yun-hee is initially attracted to the Muoi legend because she is desperate to write another best-selling book and doesn’t really care who she hurts in order to do it. This self-conscious commentary about the eagerness of potential audiences to consume stories of other’s misfortunes gives a layer of spectatorial discomfort to the watching of this film that is missing from many other examples of the genre.

Sunday, January 5, 2014

Murakami/Rabinowitz/TheBigHeat


Today I read the last fifty pages of Hard-Boiled Wonderland. The Caluctec finishes his last day by spending it with the Librarian, eating, making love, and then finally driving to the waterfront to listen to Bob Dylan in his rental car as he fades out of consciousness for the last time. In the meantime, the Dreamreader is with his Librarian, whom he has clearly fallen in love with, and whose mind he has dedicated himself to recovering from the skulls stored in the library. Before we can be sure whether or not he succeeds, he leaves to meet his Shadow and escape from the Town. Although the Shadow tries to persuade him to leave the Town by swimming into the Southern Pool, at the last minute the Dreamreader refuses and decides to stay in the Town, feeling responsible for its inhabitants and hoping to help them in some way. This is definitely a novel that finishes with a whimper rather than a bang, but perhaps that’s the point. Despite being cast in the form of genre fictions (the mystery and fantasy fiction) this is ultimately a novel about mind and consciousness, not adventure. The move from one level or type of consciousness to another is not accomplished without conflict, but that conflict is secondary to the feeling of gradual fading and continuity that dominates these final pages.

I also read the last fifty pages of Paula Rabinowitz’s Black & White & Noir: America’s Pulp Modernism. I find myself having to revise what I said in my previous post about incoherence not being a major problem in this book. Although that is still true on the whole, the exception is Rabinowitz’s chapter on the connections between early radical feminism and 1960s avant garde film culture in the US. Quite frankly, despite the interest of the subject matter, this chapter does not belong in the book. Even Rabinowitz has to admit that it is apparently disconnected from the rest of the book’s focus on pulp modernism, but she also argues that “the same process by which cultural form anticipates political action is at work.” Maybe so, but absent any demonstrable connection to noir, this material reads like part of an unrelated project. In her final chapter, “Mapping Noir,” Rabinowitz makes one of the most expansive claims in the book when she describes Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter as establishing the basic formula for film noir, in the sense that “a noir plot underlay the entire history of this continent.” Although this is a claim that can be neither proved nor disproved definitively, it is fascinatingly provocative. Place this claim alongside Leslie Fiedler’s claim about the priority of the gothic in American literature, or DH Lawrence’s description of the essential American soul as ‘hard, isolate, stoic, and a killer,’ or the work of Richard Slotkin and you’ve got yourself a course or a book proposal! http://works.bepress.com/richard_slotkin/

I also watched Fritz Lang’s classic 1953 film noir The Big Heat. http://www.filmsite.org/bigh.html Glenn Ford plays incorruptible homicide cop Dave Bannion whose attempts to bring down a local crime syndicate lead to the death of his wife, a death that adds a burning desire for revenge to his determination to see justice done. The characters and situation are introduced quickly and effectively and the pace never slackens for the remainder of the film. In a film distinguished by several strong performances (including Lee Marvin as a particularly vicious gangster) the stand out for me is Gloria Grahame as Debby, Lee Marvin’s girlfriend, who transforms the standard type of the gangster’s moll into a real character who, in a key scene with another female character, describes them memorably as “sisters under the mink.” By the time Ford achieves his quest for vengeance and justice, we have no confidence that those values mean anything. Because of this, although the film ends with Ford returning to his job as a detective apparently satisfied and vindicated, the viewer is still overwhelmed with a sense of how much he has lost. Incidentally, fans of Alfred Hitchcock will enjoy seeing a young Adam Williams, six years before his role as Valerian in North By Northwest, and the wonderful Edith Evanson, five years after her great role as Mrs. Wilson in Rope. 

Saturday, January 4, 2014

Murakami/Rabinowitz/TheBigClock


Today I read the next fifty pages of Hard-Boiled Wonderland. The Professor’s granddaughter and the Calcutec, after another long journey, make it back to the surface, where the Calcutec has to decide how to spend his last hours of consciousness. Murakami mines this decision for its bathetic humor, especially when the Calcutec has to spend some of this valuable time in the Laundromat doing the granddaughter’s laundry! Apart from that, the Calcutec’s choices are pedestrian: arranging to have dinner with the Librarian, renting a fancy car, and doing some shopping. There’s none of the kind of philosophical reflection or agonizing we might expect, partly because the Calcutec seems to have come to terms with what’s going to happen. If anything, the Dreamreader is in a greater state of turmoil than the Calcutec, partly because his Shadow is apparently about to die, but mostly because the Shadow insists that now is the time to escape from the Town. At this suggestion, the full strength of the Dreamreader’s ambivalence about leaving comes to the fore, and his Shadow is hard-pressed to persuade him to honor his agreement. Now that we know that this struggle between the Shadow and the Dreamreader is taking place within a part of the Calcutec’s consciousness, the stakes of whether or not to leave the Town should be raised but for some reason I don’t feel that way. Perhaps the Calcutec’s acquiescence to the end of consciousness influences the feel of both parts of the novel as it draws to a close.

I also read the next fifty pages of Paula Rabinowitz’s Black & White & Noir: America’s Pulp Modernism. I’m reminded of Rabinowitz’s comment at the start of this book about the seeming incoherence of its contents because the chapters range so widely over subjects with little connection to each other. What saves the work, though, is that her choice of subject matter and the observations she makes about those subjects are so consistently thought-provoking. In a chapter devoted primarily to the fiction of social worker turned novelist Margaret Slade, for example, Rabinowitz argues for the figure of the social worker as a female counterpart to the private eye, although the social worker’s nominal allegiance to the state differentiates this figure from the independence of a Sam Spade or Philip Marlowe. And in a fascinating chapter titled ‘Barbara Stanwyck’s Anklet,’ Rabinowitz discusses the fetishistic power of household objects in noir, focusing in particular on shoes as a sign of “women’s aggressive mobility in postwar urban spaces.” When every page of these chapters shoots out ideas like sparks, one doesn’t mind a slight lack of coherence!

I also watched John Farrow’s 1948 film The Big Clock, an adaptation of Kenneth Fearing’s 1946 novel with the same title. Ray Milland stars as George Stroud, the editor of Crimeways Magazine and employee of the megalomaniac publisher Earl Janoth (wonderfully played by Charles Laughton). When Laughton murders his lover, he tries to frame the man who saw him on the night of the murder, not realizing that man is none other than Milland. Consequently, Milland finds himself having to run the search for himself using the highly successful techniques he’s developed at Crimeways while also conducting his own investigation to try and nail Laughton. It sounds very complicated, but it’s all handled smoothly and with excellent pace by Farrow, and the performances from the large cast are all consistently strong. The only thing I didn’t care for was the film’s use of humor, which made it as much a screwball comedy as a noir. The movie’s screenwriter, Jonathan Latimer, is known for this combination of traits, but I thought it was overdone and spoiled the otherwise suspenseful atmosphere of the film. Fearing’s novel is much darker and communicates Stroud’s paranoia much more vividly. http://www.nybooks.com/books/imprints/classics/the-big-clock/

Friday, January 3, 2014

Murakami/Rabinowitz/TheFall


Today I read the next fifty pages of Hard-Boiled Wonderland. In this section, the Calcutec and the Professor’s granddaughter finally succeed in finding the Professor, who has retreated to his refuge in order to avoid being kidnapped by either the Semiotecs or by the System, his former employers. The Professor explains to the Calcutec in great detail exactly what he’s done to the Calcutec’s brain, and why. We receive confirmation not only that the Town is located in the Calcutec’s head, but also that ‘the end of the world’ refers not to an apocalypse in the conventional sense, but rather to the imminent shutdown of the Calcutec’s core consciousness, a process that the Professor seems powerless to stop. This information changes the reader’s views not only of the Hard-Boiled Wonderland, but also of the town named the End of the World, which now takes on an even more frankly fabulistic character. My favorite aspect of the novel so far is the relative equanimity with which the Calcutec greets the news of his approaching lack of consciousness. I also love the way in which the apocalyptic overtones of this part of the narrative turn out to be both personal and mental rather than planetary; perhaps this is the way, after all, that any one of us would experience true apocalypse!

I also read the next fifty pages of Paula Rabinowitz’s Black & White & Noir: America’s Pulp Modernism. This section of the book is titled ‘White: Work and Memory’ and in it Rabinowitz turns her attention from African American culture to the noir-ish elements of white culture during the 1930s and 1940s. In a chapter on ‘Rural Pulp and Documentary Modernism,’ for example, Rabinowitz looks at the ways in which the impulses that shaped the documentary photography of the period can also be found in pop culture, including film noir. Even though this photography typically showed the heartland rather than the cities one associates with noir, Rabinowitz argues that one prepared the way for the other: “Documentary rhetoric in the 1930s reworked the form into a vehicle for creating a national popular culture, securing the city, or letting it languish, as grist for pulp fiction, a space apart from the location of political truth, until Hollywood returned to the city in the postwar years with film noir.” This argument is typical of the way Rabinowitz uses the reader’s assumed familiarity with the conventions of film noir to make arguments about less familiar materials.

I also watched the final episode of The Fall. The series left itself with a lot of work to do in this final episode and it definitely felt rushed at points. In some respects, however, this feeling of urgency worked well with the content of the episode. For example, as Spector feels the walls starting to close in, he has to work fast and efficiently to both destroy any evidence connecting him to the crimes and to set up an escape route. That he neither cracks under the pressure nor confesses but rather walks away not only leaves open the possibility of a second season but also reflects his systematic and intelligent approach to things—precisely the qualities that make him a good killer. With this nuanced depiction of Spector’s personality in mind, I was disappointed that the show chose to give him the standard ‘broken home and family’ background and that it chose to personalize the relationship between him and Gibson. To some extent, the face-off between Gibson and Spector was inevitable, not only because they are the show’s two protagonists, but also because Spector is the ultimate expression of the patriarchal culture that Gibson has been struggling against throughout the series. The problem is that the final presentation of Spector as Gibson’s antagonist individualizes him (he becomes the Moriarty to Gibson’s Holmes, so to speak) and in doing so makes it more difficult to see him precisely as the expression of a system. Is this individualization an inbuilt limitation of the genre of television crime drama?

Thursday, January 2, 2014

Murakami/Rabinowitz/TheFall


Today I read the next fifty pages of Hard-Boiled Wonderland. If there are fifty pages that could have been cut from the book, these are those pages. In Hard-Boiled Wonderland, we’re treated to an unnecessarily detailed description of the Calcutec’s and the Professor’s granddaughter’s efforts to find the Professor. They are following what they hope is the Professor’s trail underground through what amounts to a kind of obstacle course. This account of their struggles could have been much shorter. In the End of the World, the Dreamreader continues to have difficulties in knowing his own mind (both literally and figuratively), especially now that winter has arrived in the Town. Even though his Shadow is suffering more physically, he seems to maintain a stronger sense of than the Dreamreader, and one senses that if they’re ever going to succeed in escaping from the Town, it will be thanks to the Shadow.

I also read the next fifty pages of Paula Rabinowitz’s Black & White & Noir: America’s Pulp Modernism. At one point, Rabinowitz notes that the “formula for noir—guilt, knowledge, desire, deceit, vengeance, a past weighing heavily on the present, and a lone man, an outsider…provides a frame for understanding African-American experience.” With this in mind, it makes perfect sense that Rabinowitz spends a large part of this book discussing black American culture. In a chapter that addresses film noir more directly than any other part of the book, Rabinowitz develops an interesting angle on the genre by studying the figure of the black maid in movies like Out of the Past and Imitation of Life in order to discuss why there can be no black femmes fatales in film noir. And in a chapter that argues most directly for influences of one kind or another, Rabinowitz writes a very useful chapter on Richard Wright’s neglected novel The Outsider, connecting it with Wright’s better-known work in terms of his persistent fascination with black crime and the complex relation between actual crimes and their fictional recreation in Wright’s work. My only complaint with this latter chapter is that Rabinowitz misses a golden opportunity to discusses Chester Himes’ noir-influenced social realism of the 1940s. She mentions If He Hollers Let Him Go only in passing and completely ignores Lonely Crusade, a novel with multiple connections to Wright’s oeuvre, especially in terms of its representation of the American Communist Party.

I also watched the next episode of The Fall. The police corruption aspect of the plot is by far the weakest aspect of the show. Once it’s been set in motion, the show doesn’t seem to know what to do with it and I can’t help but feel that it’s there primarily to take some of the focus off the plot involving Spector and Gibson, in the sense of giving viewers a break. If the show does indeed come back for a second season, it will be interesting to see how it handles this corruption plot. In the meantime, Spector’s character is being developed in interesting ways. If the first couple of episodes were at pains to emphasize how well he balances his rigidly compartmentalized life, so that there is apparently no crossover between his life as a family man and his life as a killer, we now see him start to unravel, not just in the sense of bungling his latest attack, but also in the sense that his compulsions are starting to destroy the edifice of normality that he has worked so hard to create. The show is also very adroit in its timing of certain scenes. When Spector angrily defends himself to his work colleagues and claims that he has saved a woman from domestic violence, we are struck not only by the crack in his carefully controlled façade, so that the rage shows through momentarily in a non-homicidal context, but also by the lack of irony in his claim to have done the right thing. In other words, while his savior complex is inappropriate, he has in fact done the right thing (albeit for the wrong reasons) and this is just one way that the show grants its killer shades of grey.

Wednesday, January 1, 2014

Murakami/Rabinowitz/TheFall


Today I read the next fifty pages of Hard-Boiled Wonderland. It’s in this part of the novel that the themes of mind and identity begin to assert themselves much more clearly. In the Hard-Boiled Wonderland part of the novel, we learn more about what a Calcutec actually does; to be precise, we learn that a Calcutec’s training involves the extraction, reprogramming, and reinstallation of a Calcutec’s core consciousness. The Calcutec himself doesn’t know much about this process, and at this point, the reader is also not privy to the details. Meanwhile, in the Town it becomes increasingly clear that the Dreamreader’s problems largely derive from the fact that he still has what no one else in the town has, namely, a mind. As long as his Shadow survives, so will some semblance of his mind, but it is not clear whether or not the Dreamreader is string enough or even wants to maintain his mind under these circumstances. Once we find out that the Calcutec’s code word is End of the World, which is also another name for the Town, it becomes even more obvious that the two stories are interconnected. The disappearance of the Professor, and the Calcutec’s efforts to help his granddaughter find the Professor may shed more light on the nature of that connection.

I also read the next fifty pages of Paula Rabinowitz’s Black & White & Noir: America’s Pulp Modernism. This is an easy book to get confused about. It’s not really about noir in the conventional sense, and so fans of film noir and noir crime fiction are likely to be disappointed by it. It’s not even a book about materials that influence noir in the conventional sense of either ‘noir’ or ‘influence’! Rabinowitz is generally very careful not to argue for specific lines of influence (except in some cases that I’ll look at in future posts). Rather, it’s about noir as a kind of master key for America culture during World War II and in the postwar period. An example of this argument and approach is Rabinowitz’s chapter on the photography of Esther Bubley, who worked first for the Farm Security Administration and then for the Office of War Information. Rabinowitz argues that Bubley’s photos of the private and working lives of American women during wartime not only form an interesting and significant exception to mainstream patriotic boosterism but also invented “the icons of female pulp modernism—on the one hand, a kind of sleepwalking existence of endless sexual deferral; on the other, eventual economic self-sufficiency.” It’s a fascinating argument about a significant female artist of whom I’d never heard before reading Rabinowitz’s work. It shows just what Rabinowitz accomplishes here and how she does it.

I also watched the next episode of The Fall. When I first saw the scene where Gillian Anderson’s character initiates a one-night stand with one of the cops she meets in Belfast I thought it was a mistake, especially when that cop is subsequently murdered and everyone judges Anderson for what she did. Even if those judgements are clearly signaled to be a compound of hypocrisy and patriarchal double standards, the extent to which the viewer is now unavoidably focused on the sexuality of Anderson’s character rather than, say, her professional competence, initially seemed to me a distraction from the other themes the show was developing. Upon further reflection, however, I’ve changed my mind. As the murderer’s motives become somewhat more clear, it seems that the show as a whole is preoccupied with the ways in which a patriarchal culture attempts to control and judge (sexually active, professional, and independent) women by using everything from shaming to homicidal violence. In this sense, the sexuality of Anderson’s character is just as integral to the show’s goals as the murder plot.