Wednesday, December 18, 2013

O'Neill/Wee/ParanormalActivity2


Today I read the next fifty pages of Joseph O’Neill’s Netherland. In this section, the postcolonial dimensions of cricket take on a more prominent place in the novel as we hear of Chuck Ramkissoon’s plan to found a New York Cricket Club. Part of Chuck’s calculations involve not only the potential media audience for matches played at such a venue, but also the huge numbers of West Indian and South Asian immigrants in the New York Metropolitan area. In this way, O’Neill’s novel is both an immigrant novel in a long American tradition, but the 21st century version of that tradition is very different—less focused on assimilation to an American norm and more on what immigrant cultures can bring to the host country—cricket is a nice symbol for this inassimilable otherness that immigrants embody. In this respect, it would be interesting to read this novel alongside CLR James’ classic study of the relationship between colonialism and cricket, Beyond A Boundary https://www.dukeupress.edu/Beyond-A-Boundary/. More tomorrow on what O’Neill does with the personal politics (or the absence thereof) of his protagonist Hans.

I also read the next fifty pages of Valerie Wee’s Japanese Horror Films. This sections discusses the different ways in which Hollywood and Japan approach the subject of the supernatural in film. If one overlooks the inevitable generalizing, Wee makes an interesting argument about the difference between the either/or of the Western perspective on the relation between good vs evil compared with the both/and view of the Japanese perspective (influenced by Shintoism, Buddhism, and Confucianism). This difference, according to Wee, leads to a further difference in how the two film traditions treat the supernatural—it’s something evil that needs to be overcome in the Hollywood tradition, whereas it’s more a question of restoring balance and harmony in the Japanese tradition. The next chapter on Ringu/The Ring allows Wee to ground these generalizations in a close reading of the similarities and differences between the evil videos in the Japanese original and its American remake. Perversely, despite the strength of her discussion, I found myself wanting Wee to also discuss the parody of The Ring in Scary Movie 3 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zxFt3KQhkQA. What can we learn from parodies of horror movies? And what is it about the horror genre that makes it so suitable for parody?

Funnily enough, the parody of Paranormal Activity in A Haunted House that I watched the other day took me in turn to the sequel, Paranormal Activity 2. These films are a work of genius in their own way. Just think of the combination of elements from a financial point of view: a cheap cast (no stars needed) and minimal special effects (hardly any gore because they’re not body horror films) and you’ve got a winning combination. I think the suburban setting is absolutely key to the success of this franchise, not so much because a suburban audience wants to believe that their habitat is dangerous, but because that audience wants to see into their neighbors’ homes, especially prosperous homes, and be convinced that these apparently picture-perfect lives are anything but. Schadenfreude, in other words, plays a particularly important role in this type of horror film. The other reason for their success is that they have a very accurate understanding of the state of our contemporary surveillance culture. To be precise, they go beyond the truism that we are being watched by Big Brother and instead recognize that we are often all too happy and willing to put ourselves on camera, to survey ourselves in the interests of knowledge and security. This results in a situation where the actions of the family under demonic siege in this film both seem rational, in a sense, and where our voyeuristic consumption of their plight is justified because there is a mystery to be solved. For these reasons, Armand Mattelart’s The Globalization of Surveillance would be a very interesting book to read alongside the Paranormal Activity films. http://www.polity.co.uk/book.asp?ref=074564510

Tuesday, December 17, 2013

O'Neill/Wee/Cloverfield



Today I read the first fifty pages of Joseph O’Neill’s 2008 novel Netherland. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7W2ZXzM6wuI. I’ve heard this novel described as a ‘post-9/11’ novel but I think that misses the mark, and it would certainly be misleading to group Netherland with novels like Falling Man and The Reluctant Fundamentalist. It’s true that the novel begins in Manhattan shortly after the 9/11 attacks, and that the attacks are, in a way, responsible for the collapse of the protagonist’s marriage, but beyond those facts, and at least for this first part of the novel, 9/11 is not the determining event or focus of the book and it remains firmly in the background. Instead, Netherland is the story of Hans van den Broek, a Dutchman who moved to Manhattan with his young British wife when they both took up well-paying jobs in the financial sector. When his wife leaves him and takes their young son with her back to England, Hans more or less falls apart until he finds some kind of meaning in his life in the unlikely form of cricket. He starts playing with a group of amateurs at the Staten Island Cricket Club and this routine gives Hans a sense of structure and community. Based on the fact that the other members of the club are overwhelmingly Indian or Caribbean immigrants (with Hans as the token white guy) I’ve also heard Netherland described as a postcolonial novel. We’ll see whether this label turns out to be any more accurate.

I also read the first fifty pages of Valerie Wee’s Japanese Horror Films and their American Remakes. http://www.routledge.com/9781134109623. Oddly, the publication date is listed as 2014, so I feel very cutting-edge discussing a book from the future! Appropriately, the subject of the book is very timely, considering the success of films like The Grudge, The Ring, and One Missed Call, and although a great deal of critical work has been done in recent years on Japanese and Asian horror, much less has been done on American remakes of Japanese horror films, a subject that would also allow for interesting connections with the burgeoning field of adaptation studies. So far, Wee’s treatment of the subject is well-organized and comprehensive. She begins by reviewing the arguments for the cultural and aesthetic significance of horror film and does a particularly nice job of addressing the issue of whether or not film adaptations should be faithful to their sources. As she points out, part of the problem with such an argument in relation to Japanese horror films is that those films can’t be considered ‘original sources’ in the sense that they are also influenced by earlier films. She then moves on to a discussion of the representation of ghosts and the supernatural in American and Japanese horror film. One of the most interesting points she makes on this subject is that because Japanese culture has a very different relationship to the supernatural, Japanese horror films are much less concerned than their American counterparts with finding a ‘rational’ explanation for supernatural phenomena; instead, the supernatural in JHorror is allowed to exist on its own terms, as it were.

I also watched the 2008 film Cloverfield, which could be said to have a connection to Japanese film in as much as it’s essentially a transposition of the Godzilla genre to contemporary Manhattan. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IvNkGm8mxiM. I first watched this film on a flight from Chicago to Seoul not long after it was released. As it was a long flight and it was the only film I wanted to see, I watched it six times in a row. It wasn’t until I looked out of my hotel room in Seoul and saw a city not unlike the one I’d just watched being destroyed by a giant monster for the previous 12 hours that I realized what a bad decision I’d made; I felt so paranoid I wanted to just hide under my bed until it was time to go back to the airport! Despite this inauspicious beginning, I still watch the film fairly regularly because my dislike of models and yuppies is only matched by my dislike of yuppies that look like models, and so seeing a whole group of them traumatized and dispatched during the course of this film is very entertaining. I have to say that to me it’s ironic that this is a described as a ‘found footage’ horror film. Technically speaking, it is, but the suspension of disbelief required to accept the fact that the amateur videographer whose footage constitutes the film would have both the presence of mind, not to mention the intestinal fortitude, to keep on shooting throughout the film’s apocalyptic events, is considerable. Although a much less entertaining film, Barry Levinson’s The Bay (2012) does a much better job of interweaving various forms of found footage into the film in a consistent and believable manner.

Monday, December 16, 2013

Phillips/LandscapeofMurder/SherlockJr


Today I cheated and read the rest of Jayne Anne Phillips’ Quiet Dell because I was so desperate to finish it and move on to something else. In this last 100 pages, we finally get to the trial, which Phillips managed to divest of almost all drama, which is no mean feat bearing in mind that it was held (just like Powers’ actual trial) in an opera house. Although the trial would have been an obvious moment to flesh out Powers’ character, he remains little more than a cipher, a boogeyman in whose motives and personality Phillips remains conspicuously uninterested. As I mentioned before, this would not necessarily be a weakness in the book if there were other characters about whom we cared, but there aren’t. Inevitably, Emily ends up adopting Mason the street urchin as her legal guardian and by the end of the novel, Powers is safely executed, Mason is safely at boarding school, and Emily and William are safely on their way to a romantic trip to Paris after exchanging commitment rings by the graves of the Eicher children (an odd choice!). Nothing could be more sentimental, predictable, or tedious. Thank goodness I’m done.

On a happier note (sort of), I also finished Antonio Olmos’ book of London crime scene photos, The Landscape of Murder. The main part of the book consists of large reproductions of 79 of the 210 photos Olmos took for this project, and then all 210 photos are reproduced in thumbnail size at the end of the book. Each of the photos is accompanied by a short text that gives the name of the victims and perpetrators, the location and circumstances of the killing, and the legal conclusion of the case. This final piece of information seems to me to a weakness in the book in the sense that it is there as a salve to the reader’s conscience. By implying that justice has been or will be done, it both gives the reader a sense that our perusal of these photographs is socially useful and that the circumstances of the deaths are a little less bleak than they seem. I’m not sure that either of these implicit claims is true, but it does put the text and images in the book in a curious tension with each other. One final observation from the perspective of a British ex-pat who has lived in America for many years: it’s striking to me how few of these murders feature guns. It doesn’t take much imagination to figure out how much higher the death toll would be if guns featured not only in the events depicted in this book but also in the thousands of punch-ups in which the end result is just cuts and bruises. I think this is the aspect of the book that would stand out most to an American reader.

As a scholar of crime fiction, I’m always interested in film adaptations of the genre, so the title of Buster Keaton’s 1924 film, Sherlock Jr. caught my eye. As it turns out, only the title is really significant in this regard, as an example of how early Sherlock Holmes became the ‘type’ of the detective, but this is a great silent slapstick film for many other reasons. Keaton plays a movie projectionist who is also studying how to become a detective, and when he’s accused of stealing from the house of his would-be love interest, Keaton ingeniously combines these two worlds when his character ‘dreams’ himself into a movie he’s showing as a detective figure. There are the trademark sight gags and stunts that we associate with any Keaton movie (including one in which Keaton apparently injured himself quite badly) but the best part of this film is the self-referential way in which it blends the ‘real’ world with the fictional world of film. There’s a lovely example of this at the end of the film when Keaton and his love interest are reconciled and Keaton studies the love scene he’s projecting for cues on how to behave in real life. This goes smoothly until the film’s reconciliation scene jump cuts to marriage and children, which gives Keaton’s character pause! Beautifully done.

Sunday, December 15, 2013

Phillips/LandscapeofMurder/CatchingFire


Today I read the next fifty pages of Jayne Anne Phillips’ Quiet Dell. Just when I thought this novel could not get any worse, Emily Thornhill, while getting ready to cover the Powers trial in Clarksburg, VA, adopts Mason, a street urchin who tries to rob her, and sets about converting him in Ragged Dick fashion. One new set of clothes and a system of values later and presto! Mason is Emily’s research assistant. Happily, Emily still had time to have sex by a deserted skating rink with her bank manager lover William, having thankfully had the foresight, as Phillips tell us, to leave her underwear in her hotel room beforehand. I’m going to have a celebratory drink once I get to the end of this novel.

Fortunately, I also read the first half of a remarkable book, The Landscape of Murder, by Antonio Olmos http://thelandscapeofmurder.wordpress.com/. In 2011 and 2012 a total of 210 murders took place in London. Olmos decided to take photos of each one of the murder scenes, usually a few days after the murder took place. Although this project has some obvious surface similarities to the crime scene photographs of Weegee in the 1930s and 1940s collected in his book Naked City http://gothamist.com/2012/01/04/grisly_crime_scene_photos_from_1930.php#photo-1
I think a better comparison is the work done by the Los Angeles Times’ Homicide Report http://projects.latimes.com/homicide/about/. Like the Homicide Report, an important aspect of what Olmos is doing is to represent those acts of violence that the rest of the media ignores or just barely acknowledges. Even if just for a moment, Olmos’ camera and the accompanying text tell the story of a death and in doing so they invest it with the meaning of a memorial that will endure. Deliberately undramatic, these photographs capture the dreadful banality of murder, the fact that the disenfranchised and poor tend to be disproportionately impacted by it, and the attempts by friends and family to mark the scene of death with tributes to the person who has been taken from them. This book is essential reading.

I also watched Catching Fire, the second movie in the Hunger Games trilogy starring Jennifer Lawrence. Watching this movie was a salutary reminder of the fact that the meaning of a film can depend on whom you watch it with. In this case, I watched Catching Fire with my older daughter, who is a huge Hunger Games and Jennifer Lawrence fan. She loved the movie, while I thought it wasn’t as good as the first one, being much less invested in character and more in symbols. My point, however, is that my daughter’s investment in Lawrence’s character, and in particular the extent to which that character represents female empowerment for my daughter, gave me a new perspective on the hoary question of whether films of this kind have any politically progressive potential. The answer, as always, is ‘It depends.’ In this case, it depended on who I watched the film with, and the conversation my daughter and I had afterward about the movie.

Saturday, December 14, 2013

Phillips/Perec/AHauntedHouse


Today I read the next fifty pages of Jayne Anne Phillips’ Quiet Dell. In this section, we follow Emily Thornhill as she journeys to Iowa to meet Harry Powers’ father. We learn Power’s real name (Harm Drenth) and the fact that although he came from good people (horny-handed sons of the soil, no less) he seems to have been a bad seed (surprise, surprise). We then go to Chicago with Emily to see the auction of the Eichers’ possessions, which allows Emily/Phillips to feel some righteous indignation at the ghoulish nature of people, before going back to Quiet Dell to witness a lynch mob trying to break into the local jail and deliver summary justice to Powers. Sounds quite eventful and interesting, doesn’t it? Unfortunately, appearances can be deceiving. The irony of continuing to keep Powers in the background of the story is that we yearn for him even more.

I also finished Georges Perec’s Species of Spaces and Other Pieces, which includes the following pieces: “Robert Antelme or the Truth of Literature,” “A Scientific and Literary Friendship,” “The Winter Journey,” and some examples of Perec’s word games. The most interesting piece for me was the essay on Antelme, which comes from a much earlier stage of Perec’s career (1962). Sturrock’s footnote describes Perec’s attitude as ‘more political’ at this stage of his career than he subsequently became, but this is not a very helpful observation. It’s true that this essay does have a very different tone from the other pieces in this volume, resembling much more closely the traditional engagé type of French intellectual, rather than the playful tone of later Perec, but there are still important similarities. For example, in the context of discussing how various writers have treated the concentration camp experience, Perec singles out Antelme for praise because, rather than emphasizing the emotive, apocalyptic, or spectacular, Antelme is instead governed by “a desire for simplicity, for a previously unknown everydayness.” Even at this early stage of his career, Perec appreciated the possibilities of an examination of the ordinary, an examination he would pursue in so many different ways for the rest of his career.

Did I mention that my choice of films for discussion in this blog will be eclectic and not governed by whether or not they are ‘good’ films? If not, I think this point will be made by the fact that today I watched A Haunted House (2013), a parody of the Paranormal Activity films directed by Michael Tiddes and co-written by and starring Marlon Wayans. I’d like to say that I don’t enjoy toilet humor, constant swearing, and comedic stereotypes, but that would be a lie. I love the Scary Movie franchise, and this film is very much in that vein. Casting Cedric the Entertainer as a trainee exorcist recently released from jail is a stroke of genius and Marlon Wayans is an underrated physical comedian. For all its crassness, this film is valuable not primarily as a parody but rather as a critique of the assumed whiteness of too many examples of the horror genre. What happens when you take the threatened-suburban-white-couple that is the staple of films like Paranormal Activity and make them black? This film may not have very interesting answers to that question, but the question is still worth asking.

Friday, December 13, 2013

Phillips/Perec/ReeferMadness


Today I read the next fifty pages of Jayne Anne Phillips’ Quiet Dell. The novel is becoming less interesting the more it goes on. The character of Powers is still firmly in the background and in the abstract one would think that this decision to keep the killer out of the spotlight would be one of the most interesting aspects of the novel. The problem, however, is that Phillips has not been able to generate a character who holds the reader’s attention as much as Powers himself might have been able to. The reporter, Emily Thornhill, seems to be the novel’s protagonist, but Phillips doesn’t give us enough of a reason to care about her perspective on the case. Annabel keeps flitting in and out of the novel, but again, not enough is done with her to make her compelling. An example of a road not taken comes when Phillips includes a scene with Powers’ wife and her sister, emphasizing what kind of knowledge they did or did not have of Powers’ activities. Telling the story from the perspective of these characters could have been very interesting, but alas…

I also read the next fifty pages of Georges Perec’s Species of Spaces and Other Pieces. This includes pieces originally published in the collection L’Infra-Ordinaire in 1989. In “Approaches to What?” Perec talks again about the power of the ordinary, first by noting that it’s always the extraordinary and the cataclysmic that grabs our attention, and then by asking how we should then account for that which usually escapes our notice: “How should we take account of, question, describe what happens every day and recurs every day: the banal, the quotidian, the obvious, the common, the ordinary, the infra-ordinary, the background noise, the habitual?” The other two pieces in this section of the book can be read as answers to this question. “The Rue Vilin” consists of Perec’s descriptive notes of a single street visited on a number of occasions over a period of years, whereas “Two Hundred and Forty-three Postcards in Real Color” (written for Italo Calvino) is made up of 243 banal postcards that list a location, an activity, and a greeting. Reading all 243 is actually quite difficult because they are so banal and repetitive but eventually one settles into a rhythm of reading and then the minute variations in the ordinary start to become both more apparent and more weighty. Incidentally, for those who know Slavoj Žižek, I found Perec’s distinction between the extraordinary and the ordinary reminiscent of Žižek’s distinction between visible and invisible violence in his short book Violence: Six Sideways Reflections. According to Žižek, it’s always the first that grabs our attention, but we need to try and see the second type.

I also watched the infamous 1936 propaganda film directed by Louis Gasnier, Reefer Madness. http://web.archive.org/web/20060328163318/http://www.reefer-madness-movie.com/history.html Of course, I’d heard a lot about this film, but this is the first time I’d actually watched it from start to finish. It certainly lives up to its reputation in terms of its awful acting, its hysterical condemnation of marijuana, and its laughable hysteria about the dangers of weed, and yet there was something else about it that I didn’t anticipate. First, it was interesting how drugs are not racialized in this movie by having any connection with African Americans. Instead, both the pushers and the users in this movie are middle-class white Americans. In this respect, Reefer Madness is unusually accurate in its depiction of who sells and buy drugs in the US, much more so than most films on this subject. Second, while Reefer Madness should indeed be laughed at, we should not assume that we’ve moved on very far from this kind of anti-drugs hysteria. Here’s a story I came across the other day: https://www.change.org/petitions/president-obama-commutation-for-weldon-angelos-55-years-for-marijuana?utm_source=action_alert&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=43498&alert_id=lTrGzXTBEr_ZFAISBQiCp. A 55-year mandatory prison sentence for marijuana possession? Reefer madness is alive and well in the 21st century US.

Thursday, December 12, 2013

Phillips/Perec/Dahmer


Today I read the next fifty pages of Jayne Anne Phillips’ Quiet Dell. Phillips makes the interesting decision in this section of the novel to reproduce some photos of Powers’ victims, in addition to quotes from contemporaneous newspaper coverage of the case. The inclusion of the photographs (especially as they come about halfway through the book) suggests a surface similarity between this novel and true crime books, which also often come with a section of photos in the middle. The meaning of the photos, however, is different. In true crime books, the photographs heighten the journalistic flavor of the true crime approach (even if only superficially), thus making the photographs a guarantor of verisimilitude. Perhaps the same effect is intended in Phillips’ novel; in fact, the inclusion of the photographs in this case only heightens the gap between the actual people represented in the photos and Phillips’ recreation of them. For example, when the spirit version of Annabel reappears after the reader has seen the photos, still flying above the events while observing them, we feel Phillips’ strained contrivance even more than we did before. One can imagine a situation where this readerly self-consciousness about the inventions of fiction would work to the benefit of the book. This isn’t one of them.

I also read the next fifty pages of Perec’s Species of Spaces and Other Pieces. This consists of short pieces originally published under the title Penser/Classer in 1985, including “Notes on What I’m Looking For” and “Think/Classify.” Unlike the previous section taken from Je Suis Né, these selections are less obviously autobiographical (thought this dimension is never entirely absent from Perec’s work). Instead, what comes to the fore here is what we might describe as the most Barthesian aspects of Perec’s work, as in “Twelve Sidelong Glances,” in which Perec studies fashion as a signifying system. Unlike Barthes, however, Perec never lets go of a taste for absurdity (for example, in imagining the possibilities for generating new types of fashionable trends) that gives his attempts at (critiquing) taxonomic enterprises a quality I don’t find in Barthes. Perhaps the best way of describing that quality comes from the fact that Perec is both obsessed with taxonomies and at the same time realizes that they inevitably fail. As he says in “Think/Classify,” “Taxonomy can make your head spin” and consequently the best one can do is “muddle along.” Perec the structuralist may yearn for a complete and workable system, but Perec the post-strucuralist enjoys the fact that such systems are always arbitrary, incomplete, and overwhelmed by the inexhaustible complexity of reality.
I also watched Chris James Thomson’s 2012 documentary The Jeffrey Dahmer Files. Having written about the Dahmer case extensively, I can’t say that I learned much that was new from this film, and I really disliked the sections of the film featuring a Jeffrey Dahmer lookalike in recreations of everyday episodes in Dahmer’s life, because I didn’t feel those sections added anything at all to the film. On the plus side, I liked how the rest of the film was organized around interviews with three individuals who all provided different perspectives: one of Dahmer’s neighbors from the Oxford Apartments, the coroner who autopsied all the victims, and the lead detective on the case. There are moments that jump out from each of these interviews. The Coroner at one point describes the experience of taking the lid off the large plastic barrel found in Dahmer’s apartment, saying that it was “quite unsettling,” which I presume is very strong language for a Coroner. The detective explains that the clothes that Dahmer wore during his first court appearance actually belonged to the detective’s teenaged son, which gives one a new perspective on the iconic photo of Dahmer on the cover of People magazine. Finally, the neighbor mentions that as news of the case spread, she had people offering her $50 just to come inside her apartment and sit on a couch that Dahmer had given her—a mundane but symptomatic example of the celebrity culture that springs up around serial killers. And if you have a taste for black humor, you will love the brief clip from a home movie featuring Dahmer in which he says that he has been eating too much at McDonald’s recently and that he will “have to start eating more at home.” Indeed. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_7WHSmhx0OQ