Every day I read fifty pages of fiction, fifty pages of non-fiction, and I watch a movie. And then I tell you what I think of it all.
Monday, March 17, 2014
Medawar/Oeler/Strike
Today I finished Mardi Oakley Medawar’s Murder at Medicine Lodge. Tay-bodal
succeeds in discovering the identity of the real murderers (after an extremely
complicated explanation worthy of Hercule Poirot!) and thus exonerates both
White Bear and the Buffalo soldier Little Jonas. In some respects, however, the
resolution of the mystery takes a second place to the event that provides the
background for the novel as a whole, namely, the Medicine Lodge treaty meetings
of 1867. Medawar is unambiguous in accusing the representatives of the US
government (whom she names at the end of the novel) of negotiating in bad faith
and she applauds the decision of the Kiowa not to sign any treaties with the
Americans. Granted, her depiction of the events on which her novel is based
(not to mention her portrayal of White Bear) is not entirely accurate (for more
details on this see here) but Medawar’s
overall point is both clear and indisputable: despite the fact that solving an
individual murder is the focus of this novel, that murder pales into
insignificance next to the annihilation of an entire civilization.
I also began reading Karla Oeler’s fascinating 2009 book A Grammar of Murder: Violent Scenes and Film Form. The focus of the
book is an explanation why representations of murder are so central to the
genre of film, and Oeler summarizes her argument as follows: “Murder is such a
foundational scene in the history of cinema because the obliteration of life
that it revolves around dramatizes the way that cinematic representation—which
shows the photographic trace of a now absent object—always is poised between
conveying the reality of the object and conveying the loss of reality, or
disembodiment, intrinsic to representation itself.” A formalist argument, then,
but one also attuned to historical detail. For example, Oeler moves on to an
examination of the use of the close-up and montage in the work of early Soviet
filmmakers such as Pudovkin and Eisenstein in order to show how “cinema’s distilled
formal categories are charged with sociohistorical necessity.” Close readings
of individual films are balanced by a larger account of the genre’s history and
the ways its representations of violence have both changed and remained the
same over time.
As one of the first films Oeler mentions in Sergei Eisenstein’s 1925
masterpiece Strike, I thought this
would be a good opportunity to watch it again. Perhaps naively, bearing in mind
the fact that the last of its six parts is called ‘Extermination,’ I had
forgotten just how difficult it is to watch this film. Eisenstein’s vivid
depiction of the breaking up of a strike and the massacre of the workers is as
powerful as ever. Even though you know what’s coming long before it actually
happens, you still feel shocked and appalled by what you witness. Seeing it again
after such a long time, what stood out for me this time was how well Eisenstein
prepares his viewer for the (in)famous sequence at the end of the film where
the murder of the workers is crosscut with explicit footage of the slaughter of
a cow. Animals are not only present throughout the film, but that final shared
image of death is just one example of the relationship of objective
correlativity that Eisenstein establishes between humans and animals. This association
happens in expected ways (we understand that these humans are treated like
animals) and in less expected ways (humans borrow some of the animals’ dignity
and beauty, which makes their (the humans’ and the animals’) deaths even more
appalling). How many other films from this period retain so much of their
power?
Sunday, March 16, 2014
Medawar/Moretti/TheLegoMovie
Today I read the
next fifty pages of Mardi Oakley Medawar’s Murder
at Medicine Lodge. As one might have anticipated by her inclusion of black
soldiers in her story, this section of the novel brings in both slavery and the
Civil War as Tay-bodal’s investigation proceeds. The murder victim, Buug-lah,
becomes a more and more unsympathetic character as his unscrupulous control
over and exploitation of other people is revealed and the focus of the book
thus becomes less on solving his murder and more on making sure that the
innocent are not impacted by the death of a cruel and worthless individual.
Medawar also allows her reader to see the value system that produced both slavery
and, even more fundamentally, money from a Native American perspective,
providing another example of estranging the familiar, giving the book a very
distinctive pedagogical edge. Strikingly, except for Tay-bodal, Native
Americans are more or less completely absent from this section of the novel.
Indeed, Native American culture takes something of a back seat in this novel as
a whole, in sharp contrast to the first novel in the series.
I also finished
Franco Moretti’s The Bourgeois: Between
History and Literature. In my previous post on this book, I commented on
the fact that prose fiction was Moretti’s preferred way of illustrating the
points he makes. Happily, Moretti both confirms and extends my observation when
he comments “readers of this book know that prose is its only true hero. It
wasn’t meant to be; it just happened, in trying to do justice to the
achievements of bourgeois culture. Prose as the
bourgeois style, in the broadest sense; a way of being in the world, not just of representing it.” This passage
neatly summarizes Moretti’s method throughout his intriguing book. To give a
final example among many others: in the context of discussing the way in which
adjectives are “inconspicuous vehicles of Victorian values,” Moretti summarizes
the “semantic miracle” performed by the word “earnest”: “preserving the fundamental tonality of bourgeois existence…while endowing it with a sentimental-ethical
significance.” Attention to detail combined with the ability to generalize:
the hallmark of Moretti’s own prose style. He closes the book with a section on
Ibsen because “He is the only writer who looks the bourgeois in the face, and
asks: So, finally, what have you brought into the world?” The question remains
worth asking today.
Saturday, March 15, 2014
Medawar/Moretti/TopoftheLake
Today I read the
next fifty pages of Mardi Oakley Medawar’s Murder
at Medicine Lodge. Tay-bodal’s investigation temporarily gets easier when a
piece of evidence is found that seemingly directs attention away from White
Bear as a suspect in Buug-lah’s murder and toward an American soldier. However,
when the American army is prepared to execute Little Jonas, a black soldier,
for the murder, even though they still believe White Bear is guilty, simply in
order to preserve the peace, the Kiowa object and Tay-bodal is left alone at
the army camp to try and discover the identity of the real murderer. The stakes
of the investigation are now even higher. Not only does Tay-bodal have the
responsibility of maintaining the peace between the Americans and the Kiowa,
but if his investigation fails, the Kiowa may be ejected from the Confederacy
of Nations, which would mean the Kiowa would be at war not only with the
whites, but also with other tribes. One technique Medawar uses very effectively
in this novel emerges when Tay-bodal is left alone among whites; the
anthropological gaze that often structures fictional narratives about Native
Americans is now turned upon white culture, so that the dominant culture is now
defamiliarized and seen as strange and a-typical.
I also read the
next fifty pages of Franco Moretti’s The
Bourgeois: Between History and Literature. In his continuing effort to
outline the defining features of a bourgeois stylistics, Moretti turns to the ‘filler,’
namely, information and episodes in novels that seemingly do nothing or when
nothing happens. Moretti concludes that there are so many fillers in the
nineteenth century because they “offer the kind of narrative pleasure
compatible with the new regularity of bourgeois life.” Moretti perceives,
however, that this regularity was not the only game in town during the
ninteenth century; bourgeois existence existed alongside what Moretti calls
persistent “conservative beliefs.” In fact, Moretti goes on to argue, the job
of the novel was to forge “compromises between different ideological systems.”
At this point of the book, after having concentrated almost exclusively on the
novel, Moretti shifts to a brief discussion of Victorian pictorial
representations of the nude in the context of a punning discussion of the
bourgeois’ tendency to embody “naked self-interest.” It’s a striking shift
because it suggests the portability of Moretti’s method in a double sense: it
is able to discuss different historical periods and different genres. In a
telling moment, however, when Moretti attempts to answer the question “Why was
Victorianism?” he concludes that “the English nude is too petty a feat for such
a large question.” Literature (more specifically, prose fiction) remains not
only Moretti’s preferred example, but also the one that seemingly best suits
his method. Why might this be?
I also watched the
final episode of Jane Campion’s Top of
the Lake. Many resolutions, but few surprises. The identity of the father
of Tui’s baby was fairly predictable from the start, as was the resolution of
this situation, with Tui killing the father. Incest, as the most fundamental
violation of the law, had to figure in this series somewhere. The revelation
that Matt was Robin’s father was balanced by the sentimental revelation that
Matt was not Johnno’s father, thus
allowing the relationship between Robin and Johnno to continue, although
thankfully Campion did not pursue this happy ending scenario in any detail. And
as for the revelation about Al, which I gather angered some viewers because
they saw it as an out of left field twist ending, I can honestly say it seemed
logical rather than surprising to me. As the series progressed, Campion made it
increasingly obvious that Al was disturbed and violent. Even the victimization
of children was logical within the context of the series, as pedophilia, rather
than sexual violence against adult women was, for whatever reasons, Campion’s
focus. For me, the major underdeveloped or unresolved aspect of the series was
GJ and the women’s commune. Right from the start, I felt that once Campion had
set this aspect of the story up, she didn’t seem to know what to do with it. I
honestly can’t decide whether Campion intended GJ to be a charlatan or a seer,
but if it’s the latter, I must say that she comes dangerously close to being
the former, as most of her pronouncements are a mixture of psychobabble and
half-baked spirituality. And as for her final advice to Tui, that her child is
now her teacher, and she should listen to him?! The rest is silence…
Friday, March 14, 2014
Medawar/Moretti/TopoftheLake
Today I read the
next fifty pages of Mardi Oakley Medawar’s Murder
at Medicine Lodge. In this section of the novel, Medawar introduces her
victim into the story. Buug-lah, as Tay-bodal calls him, is a Bugler in the
Union army, and Tay-bodal’s chief, White Bear, is suspected of his murder when
he finds and picks up his bugle on the Plains. A mixed white-Indian search
party is sent out to search for Buug-lah, and when they find his dead body, the
Kiowa immediately capture and tie up the American soldiers because they know
things look very bad for White Bear. Tay-bodal has to figure out who killed
Buug-lah in order to both clear White Bear’s name and defuse a potentially
explosive situation, a situation that could easily go from the negotiation of a
peace treaty to all-out war. Medawar selects the characters in her search party
carefully in the sense that the American soldiers include not only whites, but
also ‘Buffalo Soldiers,’ or African Americans. The addition of Billy, a mixed
blood who occupies a liminal position between the white and Native American
communities, completes the complex picture Medawar is constructing of the
communication problems created by the coming together of these different, and
in many ways, polar opposite cultures.
I also watched
episode 6 of Jane Campion’s Top of the
Lake. Now that we know for sure that Tui is still alive and is being helped
by not only Jamie but also a larger group of friends, the show feels back on
track, not just in the sense that the mystery that began the series comes back
into focus, but also in the sense that this mystery’s impact on the
relationship between Robin and Johnno is coming under scrutiny. For example,
even though Johnno and his father Matt Mitcham are estranged from each other,
Johnno still disagrees with Robin’s decision to bring a case against Matt, not
because he feels any loyalty to him, but because he knows what the consequences
of Robin’s decision will be. Interestingly, Johnno’s disagreement with Robin’s
targeting of Matt is endorsed, at least some extent, by other parts of the
show. The fact that Matt’s drugs lab provides a livelihood for many of the
local people is not an insignificant fact; indeed, Robin’s decision to try and
shut down this operation is seen as not only naïve but also, in a way, unjust,
in that it’s putting an abstract notion of the law above the lived realities of
people with no other alternative but to work for Matt. In this respect, Top of the Lake consistently defines
justice as something that happens outside of the law. To the extent that Robin
still identifies with and is part of a corrupt law enforcement organization,
her decisions and priorities are going to be questioned by the show.
Thursday, March 13, 2014
Medawar/Hobsbawm/Moretti/TopoftheLake
Today I started reading Mardi Oakley Medawar’s 1999
novel, Murder at Medicine Lodge, the third in her
series of mysteries featuring Tay-bodal, a Kiowa healer. Having introduced this
character in Death at Rainy Mountain (see
previous blog entries), in this novel, Medawar can cut to the chase much more
quickly, and in fact we begin in medias
res, with Tay-bodal and his fellow Kiowas journeying through Osage country in
the summer of 1867 on their way to Medicine Lodge, Kansas, for a peace
conference with other Indian tribes and the ‘Blue Jackets,’ or Union soldiers.
This setting gives Medawar an opportunity to do several things she was not able
to do in the first novel of the series. For example, rather than focusing on
intra-tribal conflict (as in Mountain),
here Medawar can focus on conflicts between Native American nations, which
helps to convey important messages about the internal diversity of Indian
cultures. One senses, too, that much more emphasis will be placed in this novel
on white-Indian interactions, something that was only a minor concern in her
first novel.
I also started Franco Moretti’s 2013 book The Bourgeois: Between History and Literature.
This seemed an apposite book to turn to after
finishing Hobsbawm’s examination of the fate of bourgeois culture but also because
of Rick Santorum’s recent comments on how the term ‘middle class’ is now verboten because it’s an example of 'Marxism talk.' Leaving aside
Santorum’s idiocy, Moretti’s discussion of why the term ‘middle class’ came to
be preferred over the term ‘bourgeois’ is one of the best things about this
opening section of the book, which Moretti describes as a “partisan essay”
whose focus is “the bourgeois, refracted through the prism of literature.”
Moretti goes on to ask the crucial question of what kind of evidence literature
represents and concludes that literary works “belong to a parallel historical series—a
sort of cultural double helix, where the spasms of capitalist modernization are
matched and re-shaped by literary form-giving.” Literature, in other words, can
give us (necessarily indirect) access to “a dimension of the past that would
otherwise remain hidden.”
I also finished
Eric Hobsbawm’s Fractured Times: Culture
and Society in the 20th Century. The book ends with two pieces
that both focus on mass culture, but are in other respects very different from
each other. The penultimate essay tries to make sense of the role of mass
culture in the current conjuncture, and especially of the way in which it has
displaced high culture. Although Hobsbawm is right to say that we are still in
need of a critical language to discuss mass culture productively, I don’t think
he has any notion of what such a language might look like! In that sense, whether
he’s aware of it or not, he’s discussing the superannuation of traditional
modes of criticism as much as the superannuation of high culture. The final essay,
on the meaning and influence of the figure of the American cowboy, however,
shows that, in fact, Hobsbawm can discuss mass culture very thoughtfully.
Although he doesn’t focus overmuch on examples of pop culture Westerns, he
develops a number of insightful points about why American cowboys have a
universal status quite different from that of analogous figures from other
cultures. As is the case throughout this book, Hobsbawm is much better when
analyzing specifics than he is when generalizing. A final point: for all the
looking back he does in this book, Hobsbawm distinguishes himself by his lack
of nostalgia and golden ageism—would that one could say the same of other
writers.
I also watched
episode 5 of Jane Campion’s Top of the
Lake. At the point where Robin and Johnno are having sex in the middle of
the forest, one can’t help but feel that the series has gone in the wrong
direction, but has it? Answering that question depends on the answer to another
question: what is the relationship between Robin’s personal life and the
pregnancy and disappearance of Tui? If one interprets Top of the Lake too narrowly as a police procedural, then the
moment Tui disappears and the focus shifts to Robin’s attempt to work through
the traumatic events of her past is the moment when the series loses its
direction and purpose. But clearly Campion is doing something much more than a
standard (or even a reinvented) police procedural. For one thing, the police
are seen as corrupt and ineffective, and Robin’s association with them is more
a matter of convenience than a reflection of a shared belief structure. In this
sense, Robin’s temporary dismissal from the police serves to accentuate how
distant she is from this institution. With this said, although one can see the
importance of her relationship with Johnno in terms of Robin’s healing, there’s
no denying the fact that by the time we get to that scene in the woods, we are
a very long way from the original mystery indeed. I still can’t shake the
feeling that Campion is trying to do too much in too short a time and the
evidence for this is not only the lack of fit between the various threads of
the plot but also the fact that some characters (for example, Robin’s mother
and GJ) are seriously underdeveloped. With two episodes left, it will be
interesting to see to what extent, if at all, Campion is interested in resolving
the various plots.
Wednesday, March 12, 2014
Hillerman/Hobsbawm/JackFrost
Today I finished
Tony Hillerman’s 2006 novel, The Shape
Shifter. The novel climaxes, appropriately enough, with a confrontation
with the ‘shape shifter’ of the title. As was increasingly clear in the last
part of the book, Jason Delos and Ray Shewnack, the wanted criminal who had
supposedly died in a fire many years before, are in fact one and the same
person. The twist in the ending comes not only in the form of who ultimately
dispenses justice to Delos, but also in the fact that this revelation of
identity is not definitive. In other words, Shewnack was also an assumed
identity, and the true identity of the man who dies at the end of the novel
remains a mystery. Although this is not one of Hillerman’s best outings, what
he does with Leaphorn at the end of the novel is genuinely surprising and
suggests that this character is still capable of evolving and changing even
though he has supposedly left his identity as a lawman behind.
I also read the next
fifty pages of Eric Hobsbawm’s Fractured
Times: Culture and Society in the 20th Century. In this section
of the book, Hobsbawm turns his attention to religion and art, but not
(regrettably) to the relation between them. In “The Prospect of Public
Religion,” Hobsbawm tries to make sense of the combination of the manifest
decline in religious belief and observance over the course of the twentieth
century along with the fact that religion still maintains some kind of
influence over many aspects of public life around the globe. He concludes by
pointing to the “paradox of revived religious fundamentalism that it sprang
from a world where existence rests on techno-scientific foundations that are
incompatible with it, but remain indispensable even to the pious.” And in three
shorter pieces, Hobsbawm examines the relationship of (avant-garde) art to
revolution and power. In all three pieces, Hobsbawm seeks to clip the wings of
the truism that such art is truly world-changing in any substantive sense.
Rather, he says, whatever influence it did have was limited both geographically
and temporally, so much so that Hobsbawm says quite flatly that “changing
society is more than schools of art and design alone can achieve.”
Tuesday, March 11, 2014
Hillerman/Hobsbawm/TopoftheLake
Today I read the
next section of Tony Hillerman’s 2006 novel The
Shape Shifter. Hillerman develops a transnational dimension to Leaphorn’s
investigation by introducing the possibility that Jason Delos used to be a CIA
agent who was allowed to leave the agency after misusing funds during the
Vietnam War. Hillerman draws a parallel between American imperialism and
internal colonialism within the United States by having Leaphorn bond with
Delos’ assistant/servant/virtual slave Tommy Vang, a Hmong who Delos brought
back from Vietnam with him. In an extended conversation, Leaphorn and Vang find
many parallels between the histories of their respective peoples. It’s worth
mentioning that Leaphorn and Vang get this opportunity to bond when Vang is
trying to retrieve a slice of poisoned fruitcake that Delos gave Leaphorn in an
attempt to kill him off. A poisoned maraschino cherry seems like such a bizarre
choice of murder weapon for Hillerman that it resembles the eruption of an
Agatha Christie moment in a novel that is otherwise its polar opposite!
I also read the next
fifty pages of Eric Hobsbawm’s Fractured
Times: Culture and Society in the 20th Century. Not
surprisingly, a connecting thread that runs through what are in other ways
unconnected short pieces in this section of the book is an interest in the history
and fate of intellectuals. One form this interest takes is Hobsbawm’s reviews
of biographies of famous twentieth-century scientists. His discussions of J.D.
Bernal and Joseph Needham emphasize not only the personal peculiarities of
these figures, peculiarities that perhaps stopped them from having as
distinguished a career as they might otherwise have enjoyed, but also the range
of their interests and accomplishments. Without saying so explicitly, one can
imagine that Hobsbawm would be skeptical of the excessive specialization that
characterizes research in both the arts and the sciences today. Hobsbawm is
also concerned about the fact that in many ways we appear to be living in a
post-intellectual age, or at least in an age where intellectuals have less
public prominence than before (he mentions Noam Chomsky as an honorable
exception to this rule). This may be true, but one can’t help but feel that
this is only true if one defines ‘intellectual’ in a fairly narrow (i.e., non-Gramscian)
sense.
I also watched
the third and fourth episodes of Jane Campion’s Top of the Lake. It was already clear that Robin Griffin’s
investigation of Tui’s disappearance was extremely personal, but that aspect of
the plot intensifies dramatically in these two episodes. Coming back to Lake
Top in the first place has immersed Robin back in her traumatic past,
epitomized by her being gang raped as a fifteen-year-old, an event that led to
her and her mother leaving for Australia, where Robin gave birth to a child. Finding
Tui and ensuring that she receives justice is obviously a way for Robin to
process what happened in her own life, which means that her frustration with
what she sees (accurately) as the inaction and possible corruption of the local
police builds up and eventually boils over when she recognizes and assaults one
of her attackers. Two other aspects of these episodes struck me. The first
involves a local man, a convicted pedophile, who is identified as a suspect in Tui’s
disappearance and then apparently commits suicide (though it is likely he was
killed by vigilantes). His death exemplifies Campion’s portrayal of the way in
which the scapegoat figure is made to pay for forms of sexualized violence against
women and young girls that are normalized and which, relatively unspeaking, go
unpunished. The second is a feature of the show that is obvious right from the
opening episode (even in the extraordinary opening title sequence) that is, the
landscape and scenery that form the backdrop of the show. One can imagine how
its monumentality could be used to lend nobility and grandeur to what is being
portrayed (think the ‘Lord of the Rings’ films) but in Top of the Lake, it is instead used to emphasize how Robin’s
efforts are dwarfed by forces too big for her to overcome by herself. We will
see whether or not the show ultimately changes its mind about how much
difference a single person can make.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)