Wednesday, December 11, 2013

Phillips/Perec/McCarthy


Today I read the next fifty pages of Jayne Anne Phillips’ Quiet Dell. Phillips handles the murders very discreetly. Rather than getting any direct account of them, we instead stay with the disembodied spirit of one of the child victims as she observes events while floating above the scene (a gesture that seems to owe more than a little to Sebald’s The Lovely Bones). In fact, it’s interesting just how small a role Powers has played in this narrative thus far. The first part of the novel focused on his future victims, while this part of the novel is preoccupied with Emily Thornhill, a Chicago Tribune reporter who travels down to Quiet Dell, WV to cover the case. It’s hard to know at this point what Phillips wants to do with the Thornhill character, but her incipient love affair with a Chicago bank manager is less than promising. There’s a fine line between displacing the murderer from the center of the narrative and seemingly discarding that character altogether.

I also read the next fifty pages of Georges Perec’s Species of Spaces and Other Pieces. This includes the final section of the title piece (simply titled ‘Space’) and sections from his 1990 book Je suis né, including “I Was Born” and “The Work of Memory.” If I haven’t already made it clear in previous posts, let me come right out and say that Species of Spaces is essential reading for anyone working on literary and cultural representations of space, broadly defined, a field that seems to be growing exponentially these days. Given the extent of Perec’s self-consciousness about being a writer, his work is also extremely suggestive for those writing about writing, as the closing lines of ‘Space’ make clear: “To write: to try meticulously to retain something, to cause something to survive; to wrest a few precious scraps from the void as it grows, to leave somewhere a furrow, a trace, a mark, or a few signs.” As the title Je suis né implies, the writings collected under this title all have a more or less explicit autobiographical connection, but given that Perec’s life is so complexly interwoven with writing, these selections are useful even to those with no interest in his life. For example, from ‘The Work of Memory’: “For me that’s true realism: to reply on a description of reality divested of all presumptions.”

I also watched John Hillcoat’s 2009 adaptatation of Cormac McCarthy’s 2006 novel The Road. I had put off watching this for a long time because I doubted that a decent film could be made of McCarthy’s weakest (most sentimental, most conservative, most mainstream) novel. I was right, but I take no pleasure in being right (and that’s unusual for me!). I found the movie to be crudely manipulative and emotionally restricted; that is, it sounded a single emotional note from that beginning and then maintained it unrelentingly until the point of utter tedium for the rest of the film. It’s a bad sign when you want the cannibal gangs to show up in order to inject a bit of drama into the film. The boy’s reintegration into a post-apocalyptic nuclear family (complete with dog!) was excruciating. If only they had been carrying a bit of dilapidated picket fence to make the message even more clear! When I read the novel in 2006, I wanted the boy to be eaten at the end of the book, and I felt the same way about the film. Only if you hate Žižek might you enjoy this film, because Viggo Mortensen’s character resembles Žižek so strongly as he dies on the beach. Lest you think I’m too harsh on McCarthy here, I must acknowledge that at least we have The Road to thank for the toe-curlingly awful Oprah/McCarthy interview. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5RmgK0ds2d4 That’s known as being thankful for small mercies. 

Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Phillips/Perec/Miike


Today I read the next fifty pages of Jayne Anne Phillips’ Quiet Dell. Harry Powers (going under the pseudonym of Cornelius) finally enters the narrative and when he does it’s quite suspenseful. But then I realized that the reason it’s suspenseful is that I know the Powers case backwards and forwards and so I know what’s going to happen, just like I can appreciate the gap between the seemingly harmless Cornelius and the brutal reality of Powers. What would someone get out of this novel who knows nothing about the Powers case? Not very much. Could one say the same of Capote’s In Cold Blood? I don’t think so. Capote’s book has transcended the case upon which it’s based to the extent that the memory of the case only lives on in the public memory at all thanks to Capote. Could Phillips’ book lead to a revival of interest in Harry Powers? Hard to say, but my guess would be no.

I also read the next fifty pages of Georges Perec’s Species of Spaces and Other Pieces. This covers the following sections of the title piece: the street, the neighborhood, the town, the country, countries, Europe, and the World. It would be fascinating to compare what Perec says about the country with Raymond Williams’ The Country and the City. Whereas Williams sees these two spaces as intimately/dialectically interconnected, Perec’s emphasis is on a separation between the two: “The country is a foreign land. It shouldn’t be, yet it is…It’s far too late to change anything.” I was also struck by the following passage in the section on the street: “Do you know how to see what’s worthy of note? Is there anything that strikes you? Nothing strikes you. You don’t know how to see. You have to set about it more slowly, almost stupidly. Force yourself to write down what is of no interest, what is most obvious, most common, most colorless.” This passage not only sheds light on why Perec is so obsessed with the ordinary, but also on how he approaches his subject. Perec defamiliarizes and estranges the ordinary by submerging himself in it, not just impressionistically, but also with discipline and method.

I also watched Takashi Miike’s 2003 One Missed Call. I’m working with a student at the moment who’s writing his thesis on Japanese horror film, and so of course I recommended Miike, who’s one of my very favorite horror directors. This student is writing specifically about the relationship between technology and the supernatural in JHorror, so One Missed Call was an obvious choice. It tells the story of a series of murders in which the victims all receive calls on their cell phones from themselves shortly in the future in which they can hear themselves dying. The film’s protagonist, after seeing a number of her friends die in this way, receives a call herself and then it’s a race against time to see if she can solve the mystery and save her life. One Missed Call doesn’t have the intensity of Miike’s Audition or the sheer weirdness of his Visitor Q, but it is atmospheric and creepy, with a wonderful abandoned hospital set toward the end of the movie and some really thoughtful things to say about mother/daughter relations that put it in the same category as Hideo Nakata’s Dark Water (2002).

Monday, December 9, 2013

Phillips/Perec/Medvedkin


Today I read the first 50 pages of Jayne Anne Phillips’ 2013 novel Quiet Dell, which is based on a series of murders committed by Harry Powers in West Virginia in 1931 http://jayneannephillips.com/quiet-dell/. The only other thing I’ve read by Phillips is her first novel Machine Dreams, but so far Quiet Dell is underwhelming by comparison. Part of the problem is that Phillips’ decision to keep all of the original participants’ names and the locations but to fictionalize everything else inevitably recalls Truman Capote’s In Cold Blood. This is not an association that does Phillips any favors, especially as her prose style here resembles nothing as much as a tepid version of Edith Wharton—not a good thing. With all that said, the first fifty pages of the novel, dedicated as they are to delineating the lives of the family who would later be murdered by Powers, illustrates the power of fiction to do something that true crime rarely does, namely, to treat the victims as three dimensional characters in their own right. We’ll see if that changes once Powers enters the book. Coincidentally, I’m one of the talking heads in a documentary on the Powers case called Romeo Must Hang. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt1512275/

I also read the first fifty pages of Species of Spaces and Other Pieces, a wonderful collection of nonfiction pieces by the late lamented French writer Georges Perec. http://www.drunkenboat.com/db8/oulipo/feature-oulipo/essays/magne/oulibio.html
For those who have never heard of Perec, or have heard of him and have been daunted by either the sheer size of Life: A User’s Manual, his magnum opus, or the weirdness of A Void, a 300-page+ novel written without using the letter ‘e,’ Species of Spaces is a great place to start. All of the hallmarks of the Perec style are here: the whimsical, fanciful humor; the obsession with classification, and the tendency to go off on so many tangents that one quickly (and delightfully) loses the distinction between the main path and the detour. After a useful introduction by John Sturrock, the first fifty pages of the book are taken up by the first parts of the title piece, Species of Spaces, which examines the various ways in which we occupy domestic and urban space. Moving from smaller to larger spaces, Perec begins with ‘the page’ before moving on to beds, bedrooms, apartments and apartment buildings. My favorite moment is when Perec tries to imagine a room in an apartment that would be “absolutely and intentionally useless." Perec takes this wonderful premise and runs with it as only he can.

I also watched Aleksandr Medvedkin’s first full-length film Happiness (1934). This is a satirical silent slapstick comedy with a highly stylized sets and characters meant to evoke an earlier tradition of Russian folk tales. Containing an unusual mixture of anti-Tsarist and anti-Bolshevik critique, the film follows the misadventures of a poor and lazy peasant who is exploited by a wonderful variety of villains large and small. Visually very inventive, what I enjoyed most about the film was Medvedkin’s facility with creating characterological types, especially religious types. It also contains some of the best beards I have ever seen in film and at least one character who bears a startling resemblance to Tolstoy. Here’s Medvedkin in his own words on the film’s meaning: “I'd like to tell you something that seems to have escaped the attention of the critics and journalists who've written about the film. I've never managed to ensure that people understood the real meaning of this film which is as follows. . . the peasant himself - and this is just not true of our country, it's part of the social psychology of mankind in all civilized nations - dreams of ownership. He wants a prosperous life to set himself apart from his thousands and millions of neighbors; he wants to creep ahead and have his own barn, his own horses, his own grain. In short he wants to be his own boss. Of course, for every 1,000, only one will manage it; the other 999 will remain farm-hands and starve, but this dream lives on among the peasants. So Happiness is a satirical picture. I made it as the nail in the coffin of this rosy dream. I ridiculed that dream because it's unrealistic; 999 people out of 1,000 get nothing from a dream like that." http://www.silentsaregolden.com/debartoloreviews/rdbhappiness.html

Sound familiar?!

Sunday, December 8, 2013

Today is my 50th birthday, so it seems like an auspicious/inevitable time to start this blog, 50 50 & A Movie. Starting tomorrow, I'll read 50 pages of fiction, 50 pages of nonfiction, and watch a movie every day, without fail. And then I'll tell you about them. Why? I'll let you know when I figure that out.